Although it’s individual members are generally, as in the case
of Britain, elected members of national parliaments, as a body,
it is not answerable to any elected institution.
It is the policy making institution of the E.U., backed by
the powerful Committee of Permanent Representatives - a body of
appointed paid civil servants. The make up of the Council
depends on what is being discussed – foreign ministers discuss
foreign policy, agriculture ministers farming, the Common
Agricultural Policy etc. Decisions are made unanimously, or by
"qualified majority", which was extended to new areas
in place of unanimity by the Single European Act and the
Maastricht Treaty thus removing the power of national veto, and
is being extended still further by the Amsterdam Treaty.
The Maastricht Treaty introduced and made mandatory,
co-operation between member states in criminal and civil justice
and home affairs. Common positions and joint actions in this
area are implemented by the Council acting alone, the other
institutions at best are "associated" with the work as
in the case of the Commission, or just make recommendations, as
in the case of the European Parliament.
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
- meets behind closed doors.
Appointed - 20 members, 1 to 2 per state.
It alone initiates legislation by turning the policy
decisions of the Council of Ministers into legislative
"proposals" which eventually become "Community
acts" binding on member states. It is backed by about 13000
appointed paid civil servants (excluding translators).
Commissioners are forbidden by the Treaty of Rome to represent
their national interests – they must promote and represent the
interests of the Union. (whatever they may be – their own and
those of big business perhaps which in practice has easy access
to the Commission, not readily granted to anyone else.)
EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT
626 elected members of which
Britain returns 87.
It is an assembly rather than a parliament, because it cannot
initiate legislation, (it can only "ask" the
Commission to do so) and it has no control over money supply or
taxation.
It gives opinions on some matters, can be
"consulted" on others but only in certain cases can it
amend or reject a legislative proposal with the
"co-decision procedure", a very complex procedure
involving strict time limits which favours legislative proposals
going through unchallenged, especially in view of the very large
numbers of proposals that are put forward. Although the
Amsterdam Treaty extended the areas in which the
"co-decision" procedure applies, it did not simplify
the procedure itself or affect the Commission’s sole power to
initiate legislation.
In fact the number of legislative proposals in the form of
regulations and directives is so enormous that MEPs have to vote
on large numbers of them at a time with little or no knowledge
as to what the proposals involve. This also stifles debate –
for those few proposals which get debated, strict time limits of
just a few minutes are imposed on how long an individual MEP can
speak.
Democracy also requires accessibility – originally, each
constituency has an electorate of about half a million people,
but these have been replaced now by larger regions having a set
number of MEPs, making these people seem even more distant than
they were before. The Parliament sitting in Brussels and
Strasbourg is very remote as far as the electors are concerned.
Lobbying is much easier for big corporate interests through
organisations such as the European Round Table of Industrialists
and almost impossible for individuals and small interest groups.
EUROPEAN CENTRAL BANK
– meets behind closed doors.
Members of the Executive Board are appointed from private
banking circles, by agreement of heads of government of member
states after "consultation" with the Council of
Ministers and the European Parliament.
This is the most powerful institution in the E.U. It has
total and independent control over the amount of money and
credit in circulation, and thus the general level of economic
activity, at a given time throughout those member states who
sign up for monetary union. It will also fix interest rates.
What it decides determines levels of direct and indirect
taxation, spending in every area of economic and social
activity, wage deals, government borrowing, the budgets to be
allocated to the newly created regional assemblies etc. National
Central Banks become an integral part of the European System of
Central Banks and must act in accordance with it’s
instructions. It therefore controls cycles of "boom"
and "bust". It’s regulations and directives do not
require the approval or consent of any of the other
institutions, which are obliged to recognise it’s
"independence", by not seeking to influence it. The
only control is a judicial one exercised by the European Court
of Justice which is limited to deciding whether or not it has
acted in accordance with it’s very wide powers! Any changes to
those powers would require a new treaty.
The economies of the various member states of the E.U. are as
diverse and different as the states themselves. Such centralised
and uniform control will be totally lacking in flexibility to
suit local conditions. There will be winners -probably big
corporate interests who seek to locate and sell across the
entire EU. There will also be losers – probably smaller
businesses who in total provide many more jobs than big
corporations, but who do most of their trade within their home
state, who will be burdened with the cost of the changeover and
suffer most when centralised policy creates adverse local
conditions. In the meantime for states not yet enrolled in
monetary union, their economies must always be run in readiness
for entry regardless as to when if at all this occurs. In
practice this means tight controls on public spending so health
and education tend to suffer.
The granting of full independence, and control of monetary
policy to the Bank of England by the Labour Government
immediately after it was elected, was done to prepare for the
handing over of power to the ECB and the incorporation of the
Bank of England into the European System of Central Banks.